Download one of our supply chain, EUDR, CSRD/VSME & whistleblower compliance guides now Learn more →
Test now Personal demo
EUDR 18. May 2026 · 12 Min read

Substantiated concerns of the EUDR: obligations, risk assessment and distribution ban

Even a well-documented report can, under the EUDR, result in a product being banned from sale. This is made possible by “Substantiated Concerns”: concrete, fact-based indications that a product violates the regulation. The obligations this triggers depend on your role in the supply chain and whether your company qualifies as an SME.

Alexander Hilmar

Alexander Hilmar

ESG compliance expert - lawcode GmbH

Share:
Substantiated concerns of the EUDR: obligations, risk assessment and distribution ban
Table of Contents

Important facts

What are "substantiated concerns" under the EUDR?
A duly substantiated claim based on objective and verifiable information about a specific EUDR violation (Art. 2 No. 31 EUDR), not a general risk warning.
Who is subject to which obligations?
Duty to inform: all, including SMEs. Additional review obligation with distribution stop risk (Art. 5 para. 6 EUDR): only non-SME downstream actors.
When must sales be stopped?
As soon as no negligible risk can be confirmed, geolocation data is missing or a non-compliant ingredient in mixed products is not separable. Without threshold.
How quickly can an authority intervene?
Immediate measures according to Art. 23 EUDR generally end within three working days (72 hours for perishable products), extendable until the declaration of conformity.
What does a violation cost?
Fines of up to at least 4 percent of the EU-wide annual turnover, confiscation, exclusion from public contracts and publication of final judgments on a commission list.

Executive Summary

Under the EU Regulation on Deforestation-Free Products (EUDR), it is no longer solely the responsibility of government agencies to verify whether products comply with the requirements. Part of this oversight is shifting to the supply chain itself. The key instrument for this is“substantiated concerns”under Article 2(31) of the EUDR. These refer to specific, fact-based indications of a violation. Any natural or legal person may submit such concerns, either directly to the company in question or to the competent authority.

As soon as such concerns are received, staggered obligations come into force: duty to provide information to authorities and supply chain for all actors including SMEs; additional verification obligation with distribution stop risk according to Art. 5 para. 6 EUDR for non-SME downstream actors; permanent active due diligence obligation for operators. If no negligible risk can be confirmed or geolocation data is missing, or if a non-compliant component cannot be separated in the case of mixed products, products may neither be made available on the Union market nor exported. There is no threshold in terms of quantity or value.

Anyone who fails to respond to justified concerns risks swift and significant consequences. Regulatory authorities can immediately impose provisional measures, such as a sales ban lasting up to three business days initially, or up to 72 hours for perishable products. The sanctions under Article 25 of the EUDR go far beyond mere fines: the maximum amount must be at least 4 percent of annual EU-wide turnover. In addition, there may be seizures, exclusion from public contracts, and the publication of final judgments on a list maintained by the European Commission. In Germany, the EUDR Implementation Act governs jurisdictions and sanctions; the competent authority is the Federal Office for Agriculture and Food (BLE).

The best way to protect yourself is to have a robust due diligence system in place. This includes reviewing it annually, retaining all records for five years, and including provisions in your contracts with suppliers that grant you rights to request information, file reports, and terminate agreements.

Never miss an update on the EUDR again.

New specialist articles, regulatory updates and practical tips, straight to your inbox. Once a week, no spam.

No spam Unsubscribe at any time GDPR-compliant

What are "well-founded concerns"?

Article 2 No. 31 EUDR defines a well-founded concern as a

"duly substantiated allegation, based on objective and verifiable information, of non-compliance with this Regulation which may require intervention by the competent authorities".

This definition stands and falls with three characteristics:

Properly substantiated. A mere assertion is not sufficient. It must be based on clear and coherent reasoning that can be followed step by step. Anyone receiving the concerns must be able to reach the same conclusion on their own based on the information provided. Assumptions or sweeping accusations are not sufficient for this purpose.

Objective and verifiable. The information must be based on facts that can be independently verified. Appropriate evidence includes, for example, satellite images, reports, documents, or witness statements.

Sufficiently specific. The concerns must clearly be linked to a specific violation, such as one involving a company, a supply chain, a parcel of land, or a time period. A general statement that raw materials originate from a high-risk country is not sufficient.

This clearly distinguishes substantiated concerns from general risk warnings: Risk warnings describe patterns, substantiated concerns name a case.

EUDR Concenrs Definition
Substantiated concerns pursuant to Art. 2 No. 31 EUDR

Who can raise concerns and to whom?

Justified concerns can be raised by any natural or legal person, from civil society organizations to competitors to private individuals.

They can be addressed to:

  • a competent authority of a Member State (Art. 31 EUDR), or
  • directly to the operator, downstream operator or distributor associated with the alleged non-compliance.

In its guidelines (third edition, OJ C/2026/3896 of July 20, 2026) and in the FAQs (Version 5 of May 4, 2026, revised on August 21, 2026) has outlined a “model complaint.” A credible report should include:

  • Contact details of the data subject or the company
  • Contact details of the complainant (if possible)
  • Concrete indication of the alleged violation (e.g. lack of freedom from deforestation, lack of DDS, violation of national legislation)
  • In the case of allegations of illegality: the specific national legislation violated
  • Object of the complaint: affected deliveries, product type, product quantities, production area, time period
  • Evidence such as photos, reports, witness statements, NGO sources
  • All other information useful for the investigation

Member States are obliged to ensure the protection of the identity of whistleblowers.

EUDR Software

Make EUDR Compliance a Breeze

Our EUDR module handles geodata collection, risk analysis, and due diligence declarations all in one place, automatically, in an audit-proof manner, and without endless Excel spreadsheets.

Discover EUDR Software →

Which obligations give rise to justified concerns?

Anyone who receives a substantiated concern under the EUDR must immediately notify the competent authority. This applies to all companies in the supply chain, including small and medium-sized enterprises. The competent authority is the one in the EU country where the product was placed on the market or sold. In Germany, this is the Federal Office for Agriculture and Food (BLE); state authorities are responsible for primary production and logging in Germany.

Duty to inform: applies to all

Operators, downstream operators and distributors, including SMEs, must immediately inform the competent authority of the Member State where the relevant product was placed or made available on the market.

The following also applies along the chain:

  • Operators inform the retailers to whom they have supplied the product.
  • Downstream operators also inform their customers in the chain; in the case of exports, they also inform the competent authority of the country of production.

To put things in perspective: What downstream actors have to do anyway

Since the adoption of Amending Regulation (EU) 2025/2650, downstream operators and traders are no longer required to submit their own due diligence statements. They must record their suppliers and customers and retain this information for five years. Only the first customer following the operator collects the reference numbers of the due diligence statements. Non-SMEs must also register in the EU information system. The obligation to conduct due diligence in cases of reasonable suspicion is in addition to these basic obligations.

Audit obligation for non-SME downstream actors (Art. 5 (6) EUDR)

Larger companies further down the supply chain must also conduct their own checks. This applies to downstream market participants and retailers that are not SMEs. They must verify whether their suppliers have properly fulfilled their due diligence obligations and whether there is, at most, a very low risk of a violation.

This audit is necessary only if there are reasonable grounds for concern. Until then, companies are not required to systematically monitor their suppliers' processes.

The check can be carried out by:

  • Validation of the DDS or SD reference numbers in the EU information system (TRACES), where possible
  • Consultation of publicly available annual reports of upstream non-SME operators (Art. 12 (3) EUDR)
  • Access to audit results (Art. 11 para. 2 lit. b EUDR)
  • Voluntary request for additional information from upstream suppliers
  • If there is no visibility: cooperation with the competent authority, which can then ask through the chain to the first downstream operator

If the test is not successful, i.e. the risk cannot be confirmed as negligible, a distribution ban applies: the product may no longer be made available or exported.

Obligations for operators when determining their own risk

In addition to the reactive logic, operators are permanently obliged to have an active due diligence system (Art. 8 ff. EUDR). If their risk assessment, whether triggered by their own findings or by well-founded concerns, shows that there is a non-negligible risk, they may not place the product on the market or export it. A breach of this is itself a breach of the regulation.

No group-wide "outsourcing" of duties

In its judgment of November 13, 2025 (Case C-117/24), the ECJ clarified the EUTR: Mere access to the due diligence rules of a third party, including the parent company, is not sufficient. The market participant must carry out its own risk analysis and, if necessary, risk minimization measures. As the EUDR continues the logic of the EUTR, transferability is obvious: each legal entity in the group bears its obligations independently.

When exactly is there a threat of a sales stop?

An EUDR sales ban, that is, a prohibition on making a product available or exporting it, is the immediate consequence as soon as any of the following circumstances arise:

  • The available information (including substantiated concerns) shows that the product is not deforestation-free or not legally produced.
  • The information required for due diligence, in particular geolocation data of the production areas, cannot be obtained.
  • In the case of mixed products, a non-compliant component is neither identifiable nor separable; the entire product is then considered non-compliant. Classic example: loose bulk goods from several hundred plots, one of which was deforested after the cut-off date of December 31, 2020 - the entire batch is affected.
  • The risk assessment according to Art. 10 EUDR or the verification according to Art. 5 para. 6 EUDR by a non-SME downstream actor cannot confirm a negligible risk.

Important: The EUDR does not have a threshold based on quantity or value. There is no de minimis threshold.

EUDR Concerns Salesstop
Four constellations that trigger a sales stop

Immediate official measures

If a regulatory authority identifies a high risk of a violation during its inspections, it may take immediate action. Under Article 23 of the EUDR, for example, it may temporarily prohibit the product from being placed on the market.

This ban initially applies for a maximum of three workdays, or for a maximum of 72 hours in the case of perishable products. If the agency needs more time, it may extend the ban by three additional days at a time. This may continue until it is determined whether the product meets the requirements.

Consequences beyond the stop

In addition to the ban on distribution, Art. 25 EUDR provides for a sanctions regime, which the Member States design nationally, but the minimum framework of which is prescribed by European law.

These include in particular

  • Fines for legal entities with a statutory maximum of at least 4 percent of the EU-wide annual turnover of the previous year
  • Confiscation of the products concerned and the proceeds generated
  • Temporary exclusion from public contracts and EU funding for up to twelve months
  • In the event of serious or repeated infringements: temporary ban on placing relevant products on the market
  • Publication of final judgments against companies on a list maintained by the European Commission. In practice, this often has a greater impact than any fine because it damages a company’s reputation and can deter customers.

On top of that, there are additional costs: claims for damages, contractual penalties, and canceled transactions in the supply chain. Added to this is the damage to the company’s reputation. Experience shows that this quickly affects business customers, investors, and NGOs.

By the way: A Declaration of Due Diligence (DDS) or a Simplified Declaration (SD) can still be amended or withdrawn after the fact. You have up to 72 hours to do so after the reference number has been assigned. However, this is only possible as long as the number has not yet been included in a customs declaration and the product has not yet been placed on the market or exported.

Sanctions in Germany: The Implementation Act

Germany is implementing the sanctions framework through the Act on the Implementation of the EU Regulation on Deforestation-Free Products (Bundestag Document 21/8278). The Agriculture Committee adopted the amended draft on November 11, 2026; the final debate in the Bundestag is scheduled for November 12, 2026. The law is set to take effect on December 30, 2026.

Among other things, the government's draft bill provides for:

  • The competent authority is the BLE; for primary production and logging in Germany, it is the state authorities.
  • Fines of up to 4 percent of total EU-wide revenue for legal entities exceeding certain revenue thresholds.
  • Imprisonment for up to five years for placing on the market, making available, or exporting in violation of Article 3 of the EUDR; up to ten years in cases of serious environmental damage with long-lasting effects.
  • Seizure of the affected products, as well as temporary exclusion from public contracts and distribution bans following final and binding decisions.

The law does not change the obligations themselves; they apply directly under the regulation.

By the way: A Declaration of Due Diligence (DDS) or a Simplified Declaration (SD) can still be amended or withdrawn after the fact. You have up to 72 hours to do so after the reference number has been assigned. However, this is only possible as long as the number has not yet been included in a customs declaration and the product has not yet been placed on the market or exported.

Three case studies from practice

Case 1: Timber importer and satellite images

An EU timber importer (operator) is planning to import a batch of sawn timber (HS 4407) from a third country. Shortly before delivery, an NGO publishes satellite images showing that one of the parcels declared by the importer was deforested after December 31, 2020. The report is objective, verifiable and concrete, it qualifies as a substantiated concern.

Requirements: Notify the relevant authority immediately. The affected batch must not be placed on the market or exported. You must also review your due diligence system and strengthen it as needed, for example, through more frequent satellite monitoring or additional on-site inspections.

Case 2: Chocolate manufacturer (non-SME, downstream) and press research

A major chocolate manufacturer in the EU purchases cocoa mass (HS 1803) from a supplier that is also based in the EU. This supplier imported the cocoa mass itself, is therefore the operator, and has submitted the Due Diligence Statement (DDS). Then, a journalistic investigation reveals that the company at the beginning of the supply chain is involved in illegal land grabbing in the growing region. The report is specific enough to be considered a substantiated concern.

Obligations: Immediately inform the competent authority and the direct supplier. As a non-SME, the manufacturer must also check whether the upstream due diligence obligation has been properly exercised. As long as the risk cannot be confirmed as negligible, the product must not be placed on the market.

Case 3: Small Food Wholesaler (SME) and Soybean Oil

A small food wholesaler (SME) purchases soybean oil (HS 1507) from an EU importer who, as the operator, has submitted the Due Diligence Statement (DDS), and resells it to foodservice establishments. An environmental organization informs the retailer about documented illegal deforestation in the region of origin, with specific reference to the supply chain.

Obligations: The retailer must notify the competent authority and its supplier. As an SME retailer, it is not required to verify its supplier’s due diligence on its own. However, it must keep records of suppliers and customers and retain them for five years. Since it purchases directly from the operator, this also includes the operator’s reference numbers. The operator or the authority is responsible for conducting a more detailed review.

If you want to respond appropriately to well-founded concerns, you need functioning interfaces:

Verification and information exchange in practice

DDS and simplified declarations (SD) are submitted through the EU Information System. Following its overhaul, the system has been available again since the end of June 2026. The technical rules, including the simplified declaration for micro and small primary producers and the API specifications, are set forth in Implementing Regulation (EU) 2026/1565. Verification numbers provide an additional layer of security. There is no legal obligation to provide them. They may be requested on a voluntary basis in cases of substantiated concerns.

Operators are responsible for the collection and accuracy of the geo-coordinates (or postal addresses in the case of MSPO) of the production areas. This data is the basis for verifying the absence of deforestation. No compliant placing on the market without it.

Certification systems can support the risk assessment and provide evidence, but do not replace the operator's own duty of care. The responsibility for violations remains with the operator.

Prevention: a robust due diligence system (DDS)

The most effective protection against well-founded concerns and sales stops is a well-constructed due diligence system. Four building blocks are essential, plus consistent storage.

Country benchmarking as a risk framework

Before delving deeper into the due diligence system, it is worth taking a look at the country benchmarking under Article 29 of the EUDR. The Commission classifies countries or parts thereof into three risk categories: low risk, standard risk, and high risk. This classification is set forth in Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/1093. Countries without an explicit classification are automatically considered standard risk. This classification has a direct impact on reasonable grounds for concern in two ways:

  • Depth of due diligence: In the case of low-risk countries, information gathering is sufficient; risk assessment and risk mitigation are generally not required unless there are indications to the contrary. In the case of standard and high-risk countries, the full due diligence obligation applies.
  • Frequency of Regulatory Inspections: The competent authorities must inspect a minimum percentage of operators annually: 9 percent for high-risk countries, 3 percent for standard-risk countries, and 1 percent for low-risk countries. For high-risk countries, an additional 9 percent of the volume of each relevant product is added. A report of substantiated concerns therefore attracts significantly more attention from the authorities in a high-risk context.

In practical terms, this means that an NGO report on a parcel of land in a high-risk country will be investigated more quickly and more thoroughly by the authorities than the same report in a low-risk country. Anyone buying in high-risk regions should set up their due diligence system accordingly.

The building blocks in detail

  1. Collection of information (Art. 9 EUDR). Comprehensive data on products, quantities, suppliers, customers, countries of production and geolocation coordinates. For wood: the full scientific species name.
  2. Risk assessment (Art. 10 EUDR). Assessment of the risk of non-compliance based on criteria such as country risk classification, product and sector-specific risks, complexity of the supply chain, indications of illegal practices, reliability of documents and political and social factors (corruption, conflicts, sanctions).
  3. Risk mitigation (Art. 11 EUDR). For non-negligible risks: documented, concrete measures, such as additional information requirements, independent audits, support for suppliers. No placing on the market without documented risk reduction.
  4. Annual review. The system must be checked for effectiveness and updated at least once a year.
  5. Retention period of five years. All due diligence documents, risk assessments, risk mitigation measures, supplier data, and, where applicable, reference numbers must be kept available for at least five years from the date of placing on the market or export. This applies to operators for the entire due diligence documentation; to downstream operators and traders for supplier and customer data; and to the first customer following the operator for their reference numbers. In the context of justified concerns, this is not a mere formality: reports often arrive months or years after the product has been placed on the market. Anyone who cannot then demonstrate within a reasonable time how the risk assessment was conducted at that time will no longer be able to prove that the risk status was negligible.

The BLE’s inspection practices demonstrate just how rigorously authorities review these matters: According to the BLE itself, an inspection begins with the reference number of an individual due diligence statement, and for each criterion of the risk assessment, a justification must be provided as to why the risk is negligible or not. A point value alone is therefore not sufficient; the file must be traceable for each shipment. This is an administrative interpretation, not case law.

Simplified obligations apply to some companies. Companies that source raw materials exclusively from low-risk countries are subject to the simplified due diligence requirements under Article 13 of the EUDR: risk assessment and risk mitigation are not required as long as there is no indication of risk. Micro and small primary producers (MSPOs) based in a low-risk country must also submit a one-time simplified declaration under Article 4a instead of a due diligence declaration; a mailing address is sufficient in lieu of geographic data. The due diligence obligation itself remains in effect for them as well. These exemptions cease as soon as well-founded concerns or other indications of risk are received.

EUDR Concerns Due Diligence System
The EUDR due diligence system in five building blocks

Contractual protection in the supply chain

In practice, the verification obligation under Art. 5 para. 6 EUDR remains a paper tiger if downstream actors do not have contractual access to the necessary information from their upstream suppliers. Non-SMEs who are supposed to verify the due diligence of an upstream supplier after receiving a Substantiated Concern need reliable clauses in the supply contract, otherwise the only option is to go through the competent authority, which then inquires through the chain.

These are particularly useful:

  • Obligation to provide the DDS reference number and, on a voluntary basis, the verification number
  • Rights to information on due diligence processes of the upstream supplier upon receipt of justified concerns
  • Audit and information rights, in particular to geolocation data and risk assessments
  • Obligation to notify the supplier immediately upon becoming aware of justified concerns
  • Termination and reversal rights in the event that a sales stop is triggered or a risk cannot be invalidated
  • Liability and indemnification clauses for damages resulting from EUDR violations by the upstream supplier

In group structures, it should be noted that such clauses cannot be replaced by internal group regulations: According to the ECJ line from C-117/24, each legal entity bears its obligations independently. This also applies to contractual protection vis-à-vis group companies.

Given these legitimate concerns, the EUDR shifts part of the responsibility to the supply chain itself. The extent of a company’s obligations depends on its role. All companies must notify the authority. Larger companies further down the supply chain must also conduct additional checks and, in case of doubt, halt sales. Market participants who first place products on the EU market bear the duty of care on an ongoing basis.

Those who fail to respond risk immediate corrective actions, fines, and damage to their reputation. Those who act early and in a structured manner, on the other hand, ensure stability in their day-to-day operations.

Four specific next steps leading up to the implementation date of December 30, 2026:

  • Sharpen the due diligence system: Do information collection (Art. 9), risk assessment (Art. 10) and risk mitigation (Art. 11) really cover all relevant supply chains? Are they reviewed annually, documented and stored in an audit-proof manner for five years?
  • Establish a response process for substantiated concerns: Who receives reports? Who escalates? Who informs the authorities and supply chain and within what timeframe? Who decides whether to stop distribution?
  • Check supply contracts for EUDR suitability: Are reference numbers, information rights, reporting obligations and termination rights contractually secured, including within the group?
  • Train the chain and team: Suppliers and internal functions (purchasing, compliance, legal, logistics) must understand what triggers a substantiated concern and what does not.

The European Commission continuously updates its guidance and FAQs. Since this post was last updated, several legal acts have entered into force: The new Annex I (Delegated Regulation (EU) 2026/2102) has been in effect since September 18, 2026; newly added products, such as instant coffee, will be covered as of December 30, 2027. The information system is governed by Implementing Regulation (EU) 2026/1565. Check your product range against the new annex and monitor the enactment of the implementing law in Germany.

Conclusion

Well-founded concerns are not just a theory. They are what make the EUDR a tangible reality in the day-to-day operations of companies. Starting December 30, 2026, even a well-documented report from an NGO could prompt authorities to intervene immediately and ban sales, at least for a few days.

The responsibilities of each party are clearly defined. All companies, including SMEs, must notify the authorities. Larger companies further down the supply chain must also conduct additional checks and, if in doubt, halt sales. Market participants who first place products on the EU market bear a permanent duty of care.

It’s worth taking precautions early on. This involves three things: a robust due diligence system in which you retain all documents for five years; binding disclosure and reporting requirements in your contracts with suppliers; and clear internal procedures specifying who makes which decisions in an emergency.

This will help you avoid hefty fines, which are capped at a minimum of 4 percent of your annual EU-wide revenue, as well as potential criminal penalties in Germany under the Implementing Act and inclusion on the European Commission’s public list. At the same time, you’ll demonstrate to customers, investors, and regulatory authorities that you can be relied upon.

Frequently asked questions

Substantiated concerns relate to a specific case. They describe a concrete violation, support it with facts, and attribute it to a specific company or supply chain. General risk warnings, on the other hand, remain general. They highlight broader patterns or vulnerabilities, for example, in a region or industry, without citing a specific case.

Yes, the obligation to provide information to authorities and downstream actors applies to everyone. The additional inspection obligation under Art. 5 para. 6 with a potential ban on distribution only applies to non-SME downstream actors.

Emergency measures in accordance with Art. 23 EUDR generally end within three working days (72 hours for perishable products). The authority can extend ongoing tests by a further three days until conformity is established. If the operator himself determines a non-negligible risk, he may not place the product on the market from the outset.

No. If a product is classified as non-compliant, both making it available on the Union market and exporting it are prohibited.

He must then refrain from placing the product on the market or exporting it. If, for example, geolocation data is missing, compliant placing on the market is not possible.

No. Certifications can support the risk assessment, but do not replace the individual duty of care. The legal responsibility remains with the operator.

Alexander Hilmar

Alexander Hilmar

LinkedIn

ESG compliance expert - lawcode GmbH

Alexander Hilmar advises companies on the implementation of ESG compliance, sustainable reporting and supports the implementation of digital solutions for legally compliant supply chains. His specialist articles on the lawcode blog combine regulatory depth with practical recommendations for action.

EUDR CSRD / VSME HinSchG Supply Chain / CSDDD ESG compliance
Previous Post

EUDR for Small Businesses: Simplified Due Diligence Requirements for Micro and Small Producers (MSPO)

Next Post

EUDR Downstream Operators and the inbound process: What FAQ 3.4 really requires

y

More articles on EUDR